Life insurance helps provide financial support to your loved ones, but claiming the benefit isn’t always simple. Delays, denials, and disputes often occur, especially when someone misses a payment, the policy is within the contestability period, or the beneficiary designation is unclear. These issues can complicate even well-planned
insurance and risk management strategies.
In this article, we’ll cover five key things to know before hiring a life insurance lawyer, from when legal help is appropriate to how to evaluate the right attorney for your situation.

What to Know Before You Hire a Life Insurance Lawyer
Before hiring a life insurance lawyer, it's essential to understand
when legal help is actually needed. The following are some of the most common scenarios where support may be worth considering.
1. When Do You Need a Lawyer for a Life Insurance Claim?
Whether or not you need a lawyer depends on the specific issue with the claim. In some cases, you can resolve the matter by contacting the insurance company directly. In others, especially those involving disputes or denied benefits, you may need a lawyer to review the situation. Below are four common scenarios where hiring a lawyer for a life insurance claim may be necessary.
Claim Denial
If the insurer denies a life insurance claim, it must provide a reason. Common reasons include alleged misrepresentation, incomplete documentation, or missed deadlines. These denials can be complex to challenge without legal experience. A life insurance lawyer can examine the denial letter, review the policy terms, and determine if there's a valid basis to appeal the decision.
Beneficiary Disputes
These disputes often occur in cases involving remarriage, estranged family members, or contested wills. A lawyer can help resolve conflicts by interpreting the policy, reviewing legal documents, and representing your position in negotiations or court if needed.
Contestability Period Issues
Most life insurance policies have a contestability period, typically the first two years after issuance. During this time, insurers can investigate claims for potential fraud or misstatements on the application. If the insurer contests a claim during this period, legal guidance may help you respond to their requests or defend against a denial based on alleged inaccuracies.
Lapsed Policy or Premium Disputes
A policy lapse due to missed premium payments can lead to a denied claim. However, lapses are not always clear-cut. The insurer must follow proper notice procedures, and some policies allow for reinstatement or grace periods. A life insurance policy lawyer can review how the insurer handled the lapse and determine whether you can still pursue the claim.
2. Understanding the Types of Life Insurance Policies
Not all life insurance policies are the same. The type of policy in place can influence how claims are processed and whether legal issues arise. Some policies are simple, while others involve cash value, investment components, or trust arrangements. Understanding the basics of each can help you or your lawyer identify potential challenges early on.
Term Life Insurance
Term life insurance covers a specific period, usually 10, 20, or 30 years. If the insured passes away during the term, the insurer pays the benefit to the listed beneficiary. These policies are typically simpler, but problems can arise if the claim is made after the term ends or during a policy lapse. You may need a lawyer for life insurance claims if the insurer denies your claim because the policy expired or wasn’t renewed, especially if the insurer failed to explain the term limits clearly.
Whole Life Insurance
Whole life insurance provides permanent coverage and includes a savings or “cash value” component. Many people use these policies as part of long-term estate planning and place them in a trust. Disputes involving life insurance trust lawyers often arise when beneficiaries don’t understand who manages the policy or who controls the proceeds. Legal issues can also come up when the insurer delays a claim due to questions about ownership or the trust’s structure.
Universal and Variable Life Insurance
Universal and variable life insurance policies offer flexible premiums and sometimes allow investment of the policy's cash value. These added features can also bring complications. Common issues include underfunded policies, unexpected changes in the death benefit, or confusion over policy value. Legal support can be helpful when policyholders or beneficiaries believe there’s been mismanagement or misinformation about how the policy works.
Life Insurance for Seniors
Life insurance purchased later in life often comes with more limitations. Policies for seniors may include graded death benefits, longer contestability periods, or strict exclusions for specific causes of death. Disputes can also arise when policies are sold through aggressive marketing or without clear disclosure. In these cases, a lawyer can help review the policy terms and determine if a claim denial is enforceable under state law.
3. What Questions Should You Ask a Life Insurance Lawyer?
Hiring the right life insurance lawyer starts with
asking the right questions. A lawyer’s background, approach, and communication style can significantly affect how they handle your case. Below are key areas to focus on during a consultation.
Experience and Specialization
Not all lawyers handle life insurance cases regularly. Ask how much experience the attorney has with life insurance claim disputes, especially those similar to your situation. It's helpful to know:
- How many life insurance claims have they worked on
- If they’ve dealt with the same insurer you’re facing.
- Whether they’ve handled cases involving trusts or complex beneficiaries
If your case involves a trust-owned policy, consider asking whether they have experience as a life insurance trust lawyer.
Claim Denial Strategy
If the insurer has denied your claim, ask how the lawyer approaches these cases. A strong strategy often involves reviewing the denial letter, policy documents, and relevant state laws. You might ask:
- “How do you typically challenge a denial?”
- “What steps do you take before filing a lawsuit?”
- “Have you successfully reversed similar denials in the past?”
Their answers should give you a clear sense of what to expect and how thorough their process is.
Fee Structure
Understanding how lawyers charge is essential. Some work on a contingency basis (only getting paid if you win), while others charge hourly or flat fees. Ask:
- “Do you offer an unlimited consultation?”
- “Do you charge hourly, or work on contingency?”
- “Are there any upfront costs or filing fees I should know about?”
Clarity here helps avoid surprises and ensures the arrangement fits your budget and confidence level.
Case Management
You should know who will handle your case and how they will communicate updates with you. In larger firms, the lawyer you speak with may not be the one managing your file day to day. Ask:
- “Will you personally handle my case?”
- “How often will I receive updates?”
- “Who should I contact if I have questions?”
You want to feel confident that your case won’t be overlooked or lost in a queue.
4. Red Flags to Watch For When Hiring a Life Insurance Lawyer
Choosing the right lawyer is just as important as deciding to hire one at all. While many attorneys offer valuable guidance, not all are equally qualified or transparent. Below are several warning signs that may indicate the lawyer isn’t the right fit for your case.
Guarantees or Promises of Outcome
Be cautious of any lawyer who promises a specific outcome, such as “guaranteed approval” or “100% chance of winning.” No attorney can predict the exact result of a claim or legal dispute. Ethical professionals provide informed opinions based on experience, not guarantees. Look for those who offer realistic assessments, not sales pitches.
Lack of Transparency in the Fee Structure
If a lawyer is vague about how they charge or avoids giving a clear answer, that’s a red flag. Whether they charge a flat fee, an hourly rate, or a contingency fee, the lawyer should clearly explain how and when they will bill you. A trustworthy life insurance lawyer will also outline any potential additional costs, such as filing fees or expert reports, upfront.
Poor Communication or Unclear Responsibility
A lawyer should explain how they’ll manage your case and how you can expect to stay informed. If they avoid answering questions, take too long to respond, or don’t clarify who will handle your file, it may lead to frustration later. Good legal service includes clear points of contact and consistent updates.
No Experience with Life Insurance Cases
Life insurance law has its own rules and complexities. If the lawyer’s background is mostly in unrelated areas, such as general civil litigation or family law, they may not be familiar with the nuances of life insurance, trust-owned policies, or insurer tactics. Ask for examples of past work specifically related to life insurance disputes to ensure the lawyer has the experience needed to handle your situation.
5. Legal Processes a Life Insurance Lawyer Can Help With
When life insurance claims don’t go as planned, legal support can make a significant difference in how the process moves forward. A lawyer familiar with life insurance policies can step in at different stages, from initial filing to courtroom representation. Below are the main areas where they can help.
Filing and Appealing a Claim
While filing a claim may seem straightforward, even minor documentation errors can lead to delays or denials. A lawyer can ensure the initial claim includes all necessary information, is submitted on time, and complies with the policy terms.
If the insurer has already denied the claim, a life insurance claim lawyer can handle the appeal by reviewing the reason, collecting documents, and drafting a formal response.
Negotiating with Insurers
In some cases, insurers may delay processing a claim or offer a managed payout. A lawyer can communicate directly with the insurance company on your behalf, present evidence, and push back against unreasonable delays or settlement offers. This negotiation phase often helps resolve the issue without the need for formal litigation.
Litigation and Court Representation
If you and the insurer cannot resolve the dispute through appeal or negotiation, you may need to take the case to court. A
lawyer for life insurance claims can file a lawsuit against the insurer, represent you in court, and present your case with supporting documentation and expert testimony.
How to Choose the Right Life Insurance Lawyer
Once you decide that legal help is necessary, the next step is finding a lawyer who is qualified, responsive, and the right fit for your case. Life insurance disputes can be time-sensitive and complex, so experience matters, but so does communication and transparency.
Look for Relevant Experience
Choose a lawyer who has direct experience with:
- Denied life insurance claims
- Contestability period disputes
- Beneficiary or trust-related issues
- Negotiating with major insurance companies
- Representing clients in life insurance litigation, if needed.
Evaluate Communication Style
A good lawyer should explain:
- How the legal team will manage your case
- Who will be your main point of contact?
- How often will you receive updates?
Make sure you feel confident with how they communicate. Clear, consistent updates are essential throughout a legal process.
Understand the Fee Structure
- Ask for a detailed explanation of costs, including:
- Whether they offer an unlimited consultation
- If they charge hourly, flat rate, or work on contingency
- Any potential out-of-pocket costs (e.g., court or filing fees)
- Transparency up front is a good sign of a trustworthy professional.
Check Reviews and References
Before making a decision, look for:
- Online reviews or testimonials from former clients
- Any history of complaints or disciplinary action (check your state bar’s website)
- A willingness to provide references, if appropriate
These insights can help you understand how the lawyer handles real-life cases and communicates with clients under pressure.
Conclusion: The Importance of Choosing the Right Lawyer
Life insurance claims can become complicated for many reasons: disputed beneficiaries, unclear policy terms, denied claims, or questions about policy lapses. In these situations, the proper legal guidance can help you understand your options and take the next appropriate step.
Not every claim requires a lawyer, but when legal questions or disputes arise, working with someone experienced in life insurance law can provide clarity. A qualified lawyer will review the details of your case, explain your rights, and guide you through appeals or legal action if necessary.
Taking the time to choose the right lawyer, one with experience, clear communication, and transparent fees, helps ensure they handle your case professionally.
Frequently Asked Questions About Life Insurance Lawyer
How do you tell a good lawyer?
A good lawyer is experienced, responsive, and transparent. They clearly explain your legal options, fee structure, and what to expect throughout the process. A lawyer may avoid answering questions, make unrealistic promises, or have little experience with life insurance cases. You can also check online reviews and your state bar’s website for complaints or disciplinary actions.
How do I fight a life insurance policy?
If your claim is denied or disputed, start by reviewing the denial letter and the policy terms. You can request an internal appeal from the insurance company. If the issue remains unresolved, a life insurance lawyer can help file a formal appeal or lawsuit. The lawyer will gather supporting documents, communicate with the insurer, and represent your position if legal action is needed.
Can life insurance be taken in a lawsuit?
In some cases, yes. Life insurance proceeds may be subject to claims by creditors, especially if the policy is part of the deceased person’s estate. However, if a named beneficiary is listed, those funds typically bypass the estate and may be preserved.
What is the 7-pay rule for life insurance?
The 7-pay rule is a tax regulation that applies to certain permanent life insurance policies. It limits the amount of money you can pay into a policy over seven years. If you exceed the limit, the IRS may classify the policy as a Modified Endowment Contract (MEC), which can affect its tax treatment.
How long do you have to contest a life insurance policy?
Most policies have a contestability period of two years from the date the policy was issued. During this time, the insurance company can investigate and deny claims based on misstatements or omissions on the application. After the contestability period ends, it’s much harder for an insurer to deny a claim unless there’s evidence of fraud.
Talk to a Life Insurance Lawyer Today
If you're dealing with a denied life insurance claim, a dispute over policy terms, or simply aren't sure what steps to take next, speaking with a qualified life insurance lawyer can provide clarity. Legal guidance can help you better understand the policy, your rights as a beneficiary, and the options available to you.
At
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting, we support our clients with access to trusted professionals when legal and financial matters intersect. If your life insurance situation affects your broader financial plan, we can help you navigate the next steps with care and experience.
Schedule a Consultation
Tax/Legal Disclosure
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting does not offer legal or tax advice. Please consult the appropriate professional regarding your individual circumstance.
Blog Disclosure
This blog contains general information that may not be suitable for everyone. The information contained herein should not be construed as personalized investment advice. There is no guarantee that the views and opinions expressed in this blog will come to pass. Investing in the stock market involves gains and losses and may not be suitable for all investors. Information presented herein is subject to change without notice and should not be considered as a solicitation to buy or sell any security. Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting does not offer legal or tax advice. Please consult the appropriate professional regarding your individual circumstance.
Past performance is no guarantee of future results.
VUL Disclosure
Please consider the investment objectives, risks, charges, expenses, and your need for death-benefit coverage carefully before investing. The prospectus, which contains this and other information about the variable life policy and the underlying investment options, can be obtained from your financial professional. Be sure to read the prospectus carefully before deciding whether to invest.
The investment return and principal value of the variable life policy are not guaranteed. Variable life sub-accounts fluctuate with changes in market conditions. The principal may be worth more or less than the original amount invested when the policy is surrendered. Any guarantees offered are backed by the financial strength of the insurance company.
