The Psychology of the Investor

Jonathan McQuade • July 1, 2026

When money and emotions collide, they frequently intersect in a field of study known as behavioral finance. This discipline integrates economics with insights from psychology, sociology, and anthropology to examine how emotional, social, and cognitive factors shape individual financial choices and market trends. Understanding this is essential because it explains why people don't always act in their own best financial interest.


While traditional finance assumes investors are rational, market anomalies—like the 2021 meme stock surge—prove otherwise. Viral social media momentum can decouple stock prices from company fundamentals, illustrating how collective irrationality overrides logical analysis.


The concept of irrationality, studied extensively in psychology for its role in emotional well-being, is foundational to behavioral finance. Albert Ellis, the creator of Rational Emotive Behavior Therapy, defined irrational thoughts as illogical, distorted patterns of thinking that obstruct our goals. 


As interpreted through behavioral finance biases, common types of irrational thoughts include:


  • Loss aversion - a much stronger emotion than the pleasure associated with gains
  • Overconfidence bias - an inflated view of one’s knowledge and abilities leading to excessive trading and higher risk taking
  • Recency bias - the tendency to over-weight recent information or events believing they will continue indefinitely
  • Confirmation bias - the habit of seeking out information that validates existing beliefs and ignoring contradictory data
  • Herd Mentality - following the crowd and imitating actions of what you believe everyone else is doing
  • Anchoring - sticking to an initial reference point - such as the purchase price of a stock - even as new information changes its value
  • Mental accounting - treating money differently depending on where it came from
  • Self-Attribution bias - taking credit for good investment decisions while blaming bad ones on external factors


Recognizing we have a natural tendency to think irrationally and not a requirement to act on those thoughts as it relates to investment decisions is crucial to long term disciplined success as an investor.


Disclosure: This article contains general information that may not be suitable for everyone. The information contained herein should not be construed as personalized investment advice. There is no guarantee that the views and opinions expressed in this article will come to pass. Investing in the stock market involves gains and losses and may not be suitable for all investors. Information presented herein is subject to change without notice and should not be considered as a solicitation to buy or sell any security. Boyce & Associates does not offer legal or tax advice. Please consult the appropriate professional regarding your individual circumstance. Past performance is no guarantee of future results.

Blue gradient title card for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting, “Charts & Chat” logo in white.
By Eric Boyce • November 11, 2026
Apollo's model puts fed funds near 6.75% to pull CPI back to 2%. Inside the November 8, 2026 chart pack: a post-election selloff and record dispersion.
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting logo on blue background with “CHARTS & CHAT” text
By Eric Boyce • November 3, 2026
Core PCE has reversed out of disinflation, the bond market moved before the Fed, and defensive sectors beat growth in October. The November 1 chart pack, read.
Two men discussing papers beside a laptop, with text: “Using the RMD you don’t need for a good cause”
By Ian Kloc • November 1, 2026
Ian Kloc, CFP® explains how a qualified charitable distribution (QCD) can satisfy your RMD and support the causes you care about. Contact us today.
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting “Letters from Eric” November 2026 outlook title card, black background with white text
By Eric Boyce • November 1, 2026
Eric Boyce, CFA reviews November 2026 markets: persistent inflation, rising oil prices, market concentration, and why diversification still matters.
Blue logo for B&A Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting, with “Charts & Chat” text.
By Eric Boyce • October 29, 2026
The S&P 500 PEG ratio reached 0.68 in October 2026. Eric Boyce examines AI productivity, rising margin debt, market valuations, and investor risks.
Blue logo for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting with “Charts & Chat” text
By Eric Boyce • October 19, 2026
With 84% of S&P 500 stocks down at least 10% from their highs, Boyce & Associates examines inflation, AI spending, and bond yields in its October 2026 market analysis.
Black and gray title slide with
By Eric Boyce • October 16, 2026
Blue title card for B&A Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting, “Charts & Chat” logo centered.
By Eric Boyce • October 12, 2026
Watch Charts & Chat from October 11, 2026. Eric Boyce, CFA covers the 3.6% GDP estimate, steady jobs, higher rates, rising rents, and the stock bull market.
Black cover for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting, “Letters from Eric,” October 2026 outlook on earnings, rates and inflation
By Eric Boyce • October 1, 2026
Eric Boyce, CFA reviews the October 2026 outlook: persistent inflation, higher rates, strong earnings, AI investment, and why diversification matters now.
Show More