IRA or Roth: Which is Better for Retirement Savings?

Ian Kloc • January 19, 2025

When it comes to saving for retirement, there is often confusion around whether it is better to utilize a traditional or Roth IRA. For 2025, individuals can contribute $7,000 annually to an IRA, with an additional $1,000 if they are over age 50. These contributions must come from earned income and are separate from employer-sponsored plan limits (401k 403b, etc).



A traditional IRA allows individuals to deduct contributions for their adjusted gross income, reducing their tax liability for the year. However, taxes are paid upon withdrawal, and higher earners may be ineligible for this deduction. Moreover, they will have required minimum distributions (RMD) at age 72-75 (depending on your date of birth). Roth IRAs, on the other hand, require contributions to be taxed up front, but offer tax-free growth and withdrawals after age 59½. High earners may not qualify for direct Roth IRA contributions.


Key considerations for choosing between a traditional or Roth IRA include:


1. Tax Bracket Now vs. Retirement: If you are in a high tax bracket now and expect to be in a lower one in retirement, a traditional IRA may be beneficial since it defers taxes until withdrawal. If you're in a lower tax bracket now and expect to be in a higher one later, paying taxes now with a Roth IRA may be advantageous.


2. Tax Impact for Heirs: Traditional IRAs may not be ideal for heirs, as new RMD policies require heirs to deplete the account within 10 years, potentially pushing heirs into a higher tax bracket. While inherited Roth IRA’s do have RMD’s, they are usually tax free to the heir.


3. Other Retirement Income: Consider your other income sources in retirement, such as pensions or annuities. If these sources are taxable, combining them with traditional IRA withdrawals could push you into a higher tax bracket. Roth IRAs may be more favorable in this case to avoid extra tax burden.


While these are important considerations to make, it’s essential to evaluate your specific situation. If you would like to learn more about this strategy for your particular situation, please contact us.

Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting logo and text
By Eric Boyce February 9, 2026
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. Risks to inflation from weak dollar, rising industrial prices and wages 2. ISM Services index remains positive, labor weak (job openings) 3. Strong response in energy prices, stocks - rhetoric on geopolitical developments 4. concentration of wealth and the pending wealth transfer 5. increased stock market breadth; tech stocks in correction; net profit margin and earnings per share growth remains strong across the S&P 500 equal weight index 6. international stock diversification benefit remains even if US earnings growth has far outpaced global earnings ex-US 7. yield curve as steep as its been in more than 2 years 8. lots of dry powder at private market funds ready to deploy 9. Bitcoin/crypto showing its volatile head 10. As a percent of the total economy, capital spending by the AI hyperscalers likely to exceed the US interstate highway system in the 1950-60's and the railroad build out before the civil war
Logo for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting with
By Eric Boyce February 2, 2026
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. Economic growth estimates for the 4th quarter lower, but numbers still expected to be good. 2. Leading indicators, port container volume down; factory orders slightly higher; retail sales slight uptick 3. comments on housing supply, significant shifts in the rental market, prices likely to continue to show slower growth 4. productivity higher likely due to AI; still risks of inflation, though, due to prices paid by producers 5. dollar remains weak, metals sell-off Friday in part due to new Fed chair nominee; money market inflows still robust despite interest rate decreases 6. quarterly earnings surprises lower; description of what to expect when earnings and economic growth are both positive 7. credit issuance going to be high, followed by refinancing of 1/3rd of all Treasury paper outstanding this coming year.
Family figures under a red umbrella, with text:
By Kelly Griggs February 1, 2026
Naming beneficiaries helps assets bypass probate, speeds payouts, reduces family conflict, and can override your will. Review designations regularly and list primary and contingent beneficiaries to protect your legacy.
Logo for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting. Text:
By Eric Boyce February 1, 2026
Growth stays resilient as labor cools and core inflation hovers near ~2.8%. Fed likely pauses after 2025 cuts while leadership broadens beyond megacap tech; watch tariffs, geopolitics, and an “AI bubble” reset.
Logo for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting. Text reads
By Eric Boyce January 26, 2026
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. Decision dilemma with FOMC rate meeting coming up - sticky inflation offset by weaker labor market 2. discussion of inflation components and influences 3. discussion of wages and income 4. residential housing, rental market, home improvement spending 5. exports, gold market and gold versus treasury holdings at foreign central banks 6. institutional and individual sentiment remains strong for risk assets 7. important market rotation underway - favoring value, equal weight, small cap and lower quality 8. balance of earnings growth shifting away from the Mag 7
Family on a couch; text
By Boyce & Associates January 23, 2026
Learn how you can take charge of your family finances, manage your budget, and build resilience for uncertain economic times.
Logo for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting. Text reads
By Eric Boyce January 20, 2026
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. inflation trends heading into 2026 are favorable, pending risks from policy shocks or politicized Fed. Money supply growth also bears watching 2. Producer prices remain elevated; potential supply chain issues on the margin 3. recession probability falling, strong 4th quarter economic growth expected. First half 2026 visibility much better than the end of 2026 visibility 4. retail sales, NY/Philly Fed survey's positive; capital spending trending higher 5. labor market slowing; increased joblessness amongst younger worker and those with degrees 6. update on residential housing; oil production 7. Investor sentiment remains high, volatility low in both equity and fixed income; increased breadth in the equity markets - all sectors above moving averages 8. Lower 2 year rates steepening the yield curve; meanwhile, credit spreads remain very low - implying low risk of recession
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting logo and
By Eric Boyce January 12, 2026
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. no significant predictive investment trends from geopolitical events, especially over the medium to long erm. 2. bank lending recovering, defaults higher but not yet a problem; new business applications on the rise 3. Housing - confidence and affordability still main drivers; average monthly payments and mortgage interest rates remain sticky 4. Job market remains sluggish; job sentiment weak 5. manufacturing remains weak; service economy remains in expansion 6. Big divergence still exists for hard versus soft data; soft data is weak, while much of the observable data is more positive. 7. Atlanta Fed predicting 5% annualized GDP growth for the 4th quarter of 2025 8. Equity market concentrations and valuation bear watching; fixed income poised for better performance
Glass jar with coins and a plant on wooden background with text
By Boyce & Associates January 9, 2026
Considering alternative assets? Learn the key questions to ask, risks to understand, and how alternatives fit into a long-term investment strategy.
Logo for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting with
By Eric Boyce January 5, 2026
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. breakdown of drivers behind the 3rd quarter economic growth data and what to possibly expect in 2026, including possible impact from lingering tariffs and the OBBBA 2. inflation and wage trends heading into the new year. 3. the impact of income levels on spending, consumer confidence and expectations, as well as impact of tariffs and OBBBA on consumers by income level. 4. home prices up, but rate of growth decelerating; median home price to income ratios increasing. 5. Manufacturing activity remains sluggish in the Dallas and Richmond Fed districts, but future order growth looks promising. 6. Net federal interest rate expense will become a significant conversation during the 2030's. 7. breakdown of 2025 equity market drivers, including by sector and by factor. What to expect at least for the first part of 2026. 8. discussion of concentration risk, valuation and volatility heading into the new year. 9. more normal treasury yield curve at beginning of year; discussion of potential for rate cuts. 10.breakdown of commodity performance in 2025 and implications for potential commodity supercycle based on potential weaker dollar expectations 11.state of alternative assets in portfolios, weak crypto markets at end of year, implications of declining Chinese fertility.
Show More