A Business Valuation Is More Than Just The Number

Thomas E. Kemler, CFA, CVA • August 31, 2024

Successful business owners have a lot of ways to benchmark and track their personal financial situation.  There's apps for financial planning and securities accounts that can aggregate and display the total of all account values to the penny with just a few clicks.  Websites like Zillow and Redfin can give a fairly accurate estimate of home values in just a few seconds.  But, what about the value of their businesses?  For most business owners, the value of their business is a large part of their wealth triangle: home equity, securities accounts, and the value of the business.

In many cases, the value of the business is the largest part of the owner's overall wealth.  It might even be worth more than the other two parts of the wealth triangle combined.  However, the value of a successful business isn't going to appear on a computer screen as easily as home prices or account values.  This is why the forward-looking business owner needs to keep track of the valuation of their business.  If for no other reason, the business owner needs to fill in that big blank so they can benchmark their progress towards to their life's financial goals.

Every business is different in a myriad of ways.  Even businesses in the exact same industry can have numerous differentiating factors that affect value.  Here's just a few common ones: is the location owned or leased? What are inventory levels relative to sales? Is there significant debt?  If so, how much is it relative to equity?   Receivables aging?  Size?  Contractors or Employees?  Employee benefits?  Competition?  Understanding how these and other relevant factors should be considered within the analysis of the financial history of the business is the key to an accurate business valuation.

So, let's assume that you, as a thoughtful and successful business owner, understand all of this and choose to engage a quality business valuator.  Depending on how in-depth of an analysis that you choose is, you'll receive back a report that could number from roughly 25-125 pages in length.  But there's one thing that just about everyone does first: they find the executive summary and then scan down until they see the number.  That number represents the net sum of their main effort in their business life.   I get it.  A business valuation report is about as lengthy as a complicated tax return.  When I get my tax return draft, I immediately scan down to answer the vital questions: do I get a refund or have to pay?  Either way, how much?

Knowing the business valuation number is great.  It allows you to understand your personal wealth picture much more clearly.  It will serve as a benchmark to your progress towards retirement or your life's financial goals.  But is that all there is to it?  

The business valuation report should contain clear reasoning as to the methods, assumptions, and qualitative decisions that the valuator employed.  When I author my reports, I try to be as informative as possible.  Each step is explained and justified, and those steps are laid out in a (hopefully) intuitive progression to reach a valuation conclusion.  The valuation report is not just a number with a lot of blah-blah, legalese boilerplate wrapped around it.

The report reader can learn what factors about their business mattered, what didn't, and how much of each "what mattered" factor contributed to the overall valuation number.  The savvy reader, and this assumes that successful business owners are all savvy readers, can learn what to concentrate on or improve from these details.  This is not to say that a valuation report can replace a business coach or a consultant when it comes to improving or refining your business operations.  However, knowing what factors the business buyers' market has traditionally appreciated the most about the businesses that they buy will allow you to concentrate your improvement efforts in those directions.  

Depending on the service level of the valuation report at Boyce & Associates Business Valuations, clients can choose to receive a Zoom or teleconference call to go into the report and answer any questions they might have.  A business valuation report contains a lot of information that builds up to the numeric value of the business.  Understanding these value drivers can help you improve your business and your business's value.  

_____________________________________________________________________________________   

Thomas E. Kemler, CFA, CVA, applies almost 40 years of experience as a financial industry professional to the businesses that he values for Boyce & Associates Business Valuations. He has prepared business valuations for situations including, but not limited to, business buyers, business sellers, divorce settlements, estate tax returns, generational gifting, buy-sell agreements, phantom stock awards, principal's life insurance coverage, and SBA loan documentation.


By Eric Boyce August 11, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. Stocks have moved higher over the long term despite variations in price/earnings multiples 2. S&P 500 index is inherently different from even 10 years ago; volatility and intra-year drawdowns are absolutely normal and can lead to generous long term returns if one is patient and diligent 3. the power of long term compounded return and diversification - stocks versus bonds and cash; stocks have considerably more volatility than bonds 4. The importance of being diligent on monitoring inflation - trends in service inflation, wages provide dilemma for Fed on interest rates 5. Boom in infrastructure spending, notably data centers 6. Surge in new business applications bodes well for entrepreneurship 7. Big opportunity in offshore Asia private credit and private equity
By Eric Boyce August 5, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. The slowing in the labor economy due to tariffs, etc. 2. 2nd quarter GDP reflected reversal from 1Q - real read through is slowdown in final sales to private domestic purchasers 3. In 25 years, persons over 55 yrs of age own 20% more of the total household assets...implications for wealth planning and transfer 4. Potential implication on long-term interest rates from increased deficits from OBBBA 5. Second quarter earnings stronger than expected; profit margins holding steady amidst increased tariffs 6. Updates on housing starts/sentiment, consumer financial health, PMI data, consumer sentiment
By Jonathan McQuade August 1, 2025
On July 4th Donald Trump signed the One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBA), a law which extended many of the tax code changes made in the 2017 Tax Cuts and Jobs Act (TCJA) and added new provisions that will impact many of our clients. The bill totals a whopping 870+ pages so I’ll try to be as concise as possible.  Lets begin with the extension of tax breaks. The TCJA reduced federal tax bracket rates in 2017 and those lower rates were set to expire at the end of 2025. The OBBA made permanent the reduction in federal tax brackets. Below is a comparison of what rates would have been post TCJA without this permanent extension.
By Eric Boyce August 1, 2025
Dear Clients and Friends,
By Boyce & Associates July 18, 2025
Retiring with $2 million is a milestone many Americans dream of reaching, but what that money actually provides depends heavily on where you live and the lifestyle you envision. In Texas, where the cost of living can vary significantly by region, $2 million can open up a range of retirement possibilities, from modest and stress-free to comfortably upscale. The cost of housing alone can make a significant difference in how far your nest egg stretches, whether you're pursuing upscale city living in Austin or a more relaxed, budget-friendly lifestyle in places like Amarillo. To illustrate this variation, here’s how median home prices and lifestyle considerations differ across several Texas cities:
By Eric Boyce July 14, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. small business remain high due to trade policy 2. GDP likely to rebound - I discuss the drivers of the near term reversal and what to expect 3. US dollar weakness - what are the implications, and what is the relationship between inflation and interest rates 4. Recession probability remains low; long term inflation remains anchored 5. analysis of how many businesses are planning to pass through tariffs to customers 6. Trade war likely to take ~0.9% off GDP (per Apollo) - bigger than any most countries. 7. Analyzing debt, consumer credit and spending trends 8. Trends in earnings estimates, investor sentiment 9. college education costs expected to be up +9% year-over-year
By Eric Boyce July 7, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. Analysis of recent and upcoming economic growth and consumer spending data 2. Capital spending, housing slowing, money supply now increasing again 3. Deficit/Debt expectations 4. Updated tariff expectations on inflation, growth, etc. 5. Latest expectations for the social security trust fund 6. Trends in stock valuations, earnings and operating profit margins
featured image for july 2025 newsletter for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting
By Eric Boyce July 1, 2025
Dear Clients and Friends,
featured image for Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting post: 10 worst mistakes in estate planning
By Lindsey Sharpe July 1, 2025
Estate planning is one of the most foundational steps you can take to protect your legacy and loved ones. Unfortunately, many people make costly errors that create confusion, delay, and unintended consequences. Here are the ten most common estate planning mistakes to avoid: 1. Not Having a Plan Dying without a will or trust means state laws dictate who inherits your assets, often leading to outcomes you never intended. Do not let the courts decide. 2. Failing to Update Documents Life changes — like marriage, divorce, or the birth of a child — require updates. Outdated plans can send assets to the wrong people. You should update every 5 years at the minimum. 3. Not Planning for Incapacity Without a durable power of attorney or healthcare directive, your family may need court intervention to manage your affairs if you're incapacitated. This makes sure someone can pay your bills while you are not able to. 4. Choosing the Wrong People or too many people Naming an untrustworthy or incompetent executor, trustee, or agent can lead to mismanagement, delays, and legal disputes. Having multiple trustees or executors makes decision making difficult. 5. Ignoring Beneficiary Designations Retirement accounts and insurance policies bypass your will. If designations are outdated, assets may go to unintended recipients. I have heard of ex-spouses receiving tax-free insurance payout and not the current spouse. Check the beneficiaries every year. 6. Overlooking Tax Implications Failing to consider estate or gift taxes can shrink your legacy. Strategic gifting and trusts can minimize tax burdens. In 2025 the lifetime estate and gift exemption is $13.99 million per person. However, if Congress does not do anything, the exemption amount goes down $7 million on January 1, 2026. If your estate is more than the exemption it will be taxed at your tax rate. Example: If you pass in 2025 and your estate is $15 million, the taxable amount is $1.01 million. You would owe $404,000. In 2026, if nothing changes, your tax would be on $8 million. You would owe 40% on $8 million, $3.2 million in taxes. 7. Fund your Trust Trusts can avoid probate, ensure privacy, and manage inheritances over time. Without them, assets may be misused or delayed. Make sure you title what you can in your trust or put as beneficiaries if necessary. Consult your lawyer and make sure they walk you through how to retitle property and investments in the Trusts name. 8. Forgetting Digital Assets Without access to online accounts and passwords, heirs may lose valuable financial and sentimental property. Even if you are in the hospital incapacitated, who is going to keep paying the monthly bills. Have a plan! 9. Leaving Assets Directly to Minors Minors can't legally own property. Without trust, courts step in — and full control often transfer at age 18. If you have trust, you will have the trustee manage the assets for the minors. You have more control from the grave with a Trust. Feel free to put in there that they must be debt free other than a mortgage for a year or get an education. They must complete it before a trustee releases the funds. I do not want my 18-year-old getting a lot of money right away! 10. Going DIY Without Legal Help Online forms can’t replace personalized legal guidance. Mistakes here often cost far more than hiring an expert. Here is a real-life example, A man drafted his own will. He was divorced and had 6 kids. In the will he stated that his kids would each get 1/6% of the estate and his ex-wife would have the remainder. The kids collectively only got 1% (1/6*6), the ex-wife got 99%. All because of a percentage symbol. Just be careful. Spending the money now will save you in the long run. Avoiding these mistakes ensures your legacy is secure and your wishes are honored.
featured image for boyce & associates charts and chat
By Eric Boyce June 22, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. Implications from the bombing of Iran 2. looking ahead to possibilities surrounding the expiration of the 90 day tariff moratorium 3. foreign ownership of equities rising/US v. International valuations are well out of line with trends 4. sources of concern for consumers & probability of recession 5. private capital exits remain sluggish and new capital raises falling below recent trend due in part to uncertainty
Show More