A Business Valuation Is More Than Just The Number

Thomas E. Kemler, CFA, CVA • August 31, 2024

Successful business owners have a lot of ways to benchmark and track their personal financial situation.  There's apps for financial planning and securities accounts that can aggregate and display the total of all account values to the penny with just a few clicks.  Websites like Zillow and Redfin can give a fairly accurate estimate of home values in just a few seconds.  But, what about the value of their businesses?  For most business owners, the value of their business is a large part of their wealth triangle: home equity, securities accounts, and the value of the business.

In many cases, the value of the business is the largest part of the owner's overall wealth.  It might even be worth more than the other two parts of the wealth triangle combined.  However, the value of a successful business isn't going to appear on a computer screen as easily as home prices or account values.  This is why the forward-looking business owner needs to keep track of the valuation of their business.  If for no other reason, the business owner needs to fill in that big blank so they can benchmark their progress towards to their life's financial goals.

Every business is different in a myriad of ways.  Even businesses in the exact same industry can have numerous differentiating factors that affect value.  Here's just a few common ones: is the location owned or leased? What are inventory levels relative to sales? Is there significant debt?  If so, how much is it relative to equity?   Receivables aging?  Size?  Contractors or Employees?  Employee benefits?  Competition?  Understanding how these and other relevant factors should be considered within the analysis of the financial history of the business is the key to an accurate business valuation.

So, let's assume that you, as a thoughtful and successful business owner, understand all of this and choose to engage a quality business valuator.  Depending on how in-depth of an analysis that you choose is, you'll receive back a report that could number from roughly 25-125 pages in length.  But there's one thing that just about everyone does first: they find the executive summary and then scan down until they see the number.  That number represents the net sum of their main effort in their business life.   I get it.  A business valuation report is about as lengthy as a complicated tax return.  When I get my tax return draft, I immediately scan down to answer the vital questions: do I get a refund or have to pay?  Either way, how much?

Knowing the business valuation number is great.  It allows you to understand your personal wealth picture much more clearly.  It will serve as a benchmark to your progress towards retirement or your life's financial goals.  But is that all there is to it?  

The business valuation report should contain clear reasoning as to the methods, assumptions, and qualitative decisions that the valuator employed.  When I author my reports, I try to be as informative as possible.  Each step is explained and justified, and those steps are laid out in a (hopefully) intuitive progression to reach a valuation conclusion.  The valuation report is not just a number with a lot of blah-blah, legalese boilerplate wrapped around it.

The report reader can learn what factors about their business mattered, what didn't, and how much of each "what mattered" factor contributed to the overall valuation number.  The savvy reader, and this assumes that successful business owners are all savvy readers, can learn what to concentrate on or improve from these details.  This is not to say that a valuation report can replace a business coach or a consultant when it comes to improving or refining your business operations.  However, knowing what factors the business buyers' market has traditionally appreciated the most about the businesses that they buy will allow you to concentrate your improvement efforts in those directions.  

Depending on the service level of the valuation report at Boyce & Associates Business Valuations, clients can choose to receive a Zoom or teleconference call to go into the report and answer any questions they might have.  A business valuation report contains a lot of information that builds up to the numeric value of the business.  Understanding these value drivers can help you improve your business and your business's value.  

_____________________________________________________________________________________   

Thomas E. Kemler, CFA, CVA, applies almost 40 years of experience as a financial industry professional to the businesses that he values for Boyce & Associates Business Valuations. He has prepared business valuations for situations including, but not limited to, business buyers, business sellers, divorce settlements, estate tax returns, generational gifting, buy-sell agreements, phantom stock awards, principal's life insurance coverage, and SBA loan documentation.


By Eric Boyce June 1, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. changes in the first quarter economic growth report 2. trade and dollar comments following the trade court decision 3. Fed in tough spot; inflation v. growth worry - impact on recession probability 4. Earnings and profits expectations - likely some slowing second half of 2025 but not catastrophic 5. Richmond Fed - slight improvement in expectations, although uncertainty remains a driver 6. housing clearly still stuck in low gear due to affordability 7. analysis of hard data - order, bankruptcies, etc does not reflect crisis situation 8. discussion of strong correlation between gold and dollar 9. energy stocks imply strong pricing heading into summer driving season 10. discussion of dynamic shifts within the S&P 500 index 11. private markets slow getting out of 2025 gate; institutional investments expected to increase, but new activity appears slow
By Kelly Griggs June 1, 2025
In my previous article, “Caring for an Aging Parent,” we explored how to begin conversations with aging loved ones about their future healthcare needs. In this Part II, we’re diving into the why —why long-term care (LTC) planning is so critical for families today. Let’s start with some hard truths: 7 out of 10 people over age 65 will require some form of long-term care support. 66% of caregivers tap into their own retirement or savings to cover the cost of care for a loved one. 100% of families are impacted in some way. The importance of this topic becomes immediately clear: LTC will likely affect every single person reading this . It might be your parents who need care. It could be your spouse’s parents. And, statistically speaking, you or your spouse are very likely to need support in the future . In our financial planning practice, it’s our responsibility to address topics that can dramatically affect the outcome of decades of hard-earned savings. The good news is, there are many strategies and tools available today that can help you prepare and protect your family’s financial future. What Are Your Options? 1. Traditional Long-Term Care Policies Standalone LTC policies were widely used 30 years ago, but many providers have since exited the market or increased premiums to unsustainable levels due to rising life expectancy. For that reason, we do not recommend these policies and won’t spend time reviewing them here. 2. Life Insurance with Long-Term Care Benefits For older clients, we often recommend life insurance policies that provide LTC coverage if needed—but also offer a death benefit if care is never used. This structure ensures that your premiums are not lost, no matter what happens. 3. Hybrid Policies These insurance products combine life insurance with long-term care features. They allow the policyholder to access a % of the death benefit while still alive to pay for caregiving services—such as in-home care, assistance with daily activities, or transportation to appointments. Hybrid policies offer flexibility and peace of mind. 4. Annuities with Long-Term Care Ride Annuities have significantly improved in recent years. Today, certain annuities can double your monthly income for a set period if you experience a qualifying LTC event. For example, if you're receiving $6,000 per month in retirement income and meet the criteria, your income could increase to $12,000 per month for a period of time to help cover care costs. Be Proactive, Not Reactive These are just a few of the tools available to help you p lan ahead for the high costs of healthcare and caregiving later in life. The key is to start planning early—before a crisis hits . By doing so, you protect not just your savings, but also your independence and the well-being of those you love. If you haven’t yet talked about LTC planning with your family or financial advisor, now is the time. Because when it comes to long-term care, it’s not just about protecting assets—it’s about preserving dignity, choice, and peace of mind.
By Eric Boyce June 1, 2025
Dear Clients and Friends,
By Eric Boyce May 26, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. changing estimates of the hard versus soft landing for the economy & status of leading economic indicators 2. elevated inflation expectations and declining consumer sentiment 3. the impending impact of higher tariffs on goods vs services spending and economic growth 4. most recent 20-year treasury auction resulted in higher yields due to lower international demand 5. retail stock investors more optimistic amidst decelerating corporate earnings and cash flow 6. valuation and growth compelling in the private sector, as deal flow slowly improves 7. continued discussion on national debt and unsustainable deficits 8. Detail on housing market trends - starts are down, supply is up, prices at six month low 9. Home builder sentiment remains weak, with affordability issues persistent 10. Tremendous equity ($34T) tied up in Real Estate
By Eric Boyce May 18, 2025
In the latest Charts of the Week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. tariffs are higher overall despite the noise about levels about "deals" - watch the hard economic data in the coming months 2. producer prices witniessing margin compression 3. retail sales mixed 4. 2nd quarter GDP looking like 2.5% according to Atlanta Fed GDPNow - could be the best quarter of year, but lots of data due to be released next six weeks... 5. some credit indicators weakening; consumer is reasonably good shape. 6. tourism at 10% of GDP - is important 7. debt levels are unsustainable and will need to be address in congress/fiscal policy at some point 8. equities strong, but P/E multiples moving back higher as well - increases risk if economic data/estimates drop considerably due to economic slowdown
By Eric Boyce May 11, 2025
This week, CEO Eric Boyce, CFA discusses: 1. expected slowdown in economic growth, earnings 2. drop in container shipments from china; impact on tariffs on S&P 500, small business 3. country impact from tariffs; how china is pivoting 4. impact by sector; expectations and response from US companies 5. observations on credit, productivity, activity ahead of the tariffs 6. several data points on how consumers are planning for the next 6-9 months
By Eric Boyce May 6, 2025
Piggy bank labeled “529 Plan” on cash, with article title by Ian Kloc
By Ian Kloc May 1, 2025
It is no secret that the cost of college is rising with no end in sight, requiring further planning, strategy, and saving. The Section 529 funds are very common recommendations for families saving for college. While this is great for some families, there are good, bad and ugly aspects of these plans and some families will benefit more from other strategies. The Good: The biggest benefit to a 529 fund is the potential tax savings. The growth of the investments within the fund, and the withdrawals are all tax free when used for qualified education expenses (as defined in the IRC). Another benefit is the new 529 laws have expanded qualified education expenses to include trade schools and other forms of higher education. However, there are also several shortcomings.  The Bad: 529’s often have very limited investment options, many of which are age-based investing, often not being as adjustable to risk tolerance and preference. The family does not get a lot of discretion. Another shortcoming is they have to be declared on the FAFSA and can lower your need based aid. The Ugly: If 529 funds are not used for education, they are stuck in this account. The only options are to change the beneficiary to another family member or withdraw and pay income tax on growth, as well as a 10% penalty. While there is a new provision to roll leftover balances into a Roth IRA, read the fine print. There are a lot of strings and checkboxes attached to this provision. In conclusion, while these vehicles are still the best strategy for some families, there are other vehicles referred to as tax or asset advantaged assets that are more beneficial for other families. These assets do not have many of the withdrawal constraints and limitations of 529’s. These assets can often be sheltered from the FAFSA, potentially increasing your need-based aid. Every family needs to understand which strategy will be most beneficial for their family. Contact Boyce & Associate today for expert recommendations on which strategy is best for your family.
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting May 2025 Newsletter featured image
By Eric Boyce May 1, 2025
Dear Clients and Friends,
Boyce & Associates Wealth Consulting Market Minutes featured image
By Eric Boyce April 27, 2025
Show More